Knowledge of genres and their
conventions is deeply engrained in our minds. Even when we are not specifically
thinking about a genre’s conventions, our subconscious minds are likely
recognizing them. Playing around with genre generator websites shows how much a
genre’s conventions can mess with our heads.
One hilarious example of the power
of conventions is the SCIgen paper generator. All you do is put in the names of
the “authors” and this website gives you a decent sized paper. Now do not get
too excited because the paper is basically filled with a bunch of nonsense. By
seemingly following the conventions of an academic paper, this website has the
ability to fool readers into believing that complete nonsense is a scholarly
paper. One of the conventions that the paper generator uses is big words. Using
big words serves to make it truly seem academic and also confuse the reader so thoroughly
that they become convinced the paper is simply above their level of comprehension.
Another convention that this website abuses is figures and graphs that look
really important and scientific. The graphs are conveniently blurred to the
point where you are unable to quite make out what they represent. These graphs
also serve the purpose of making the paper look more realistic, factual, and
intelligent. Another sneaky convention that the generated papers follow is a
somewhat lengthy bibliography of references at the end. A typical academic
paper that the generator is trying to emulate would include a bibliography so
the generator knows they must have one in order to be convincing. This
generator shows that simply following conventions can make something appear
real even when it makes no sense at all.
Another interesting generator is the
comic strip generator on pandyland.net. This generator uses the same tactics as
the SCIgen generator but it follows the conventions of comic strips instead of
academic papers. The comics that it generates have two male characters and each
strip has three pictures. One convention this generator commonly uses is cuss
words. Comic strips often use cuss words for humor and this generator certainly
takes advantage of that. The cuss words are able to make the situation in the
comics appear to be funny even if it ends up being a bunch of random
profanities slapped together. Another convention the comic generator uses is
sexual situations. The comics often times depict sexual situations between the
characters or the characters saying crude sexual things to each other. For
example, Finlay very abruptly and randomly said “I am fully erect” to Simon in
one of the generated comics. The generator likely does this because, let’s be
honest, for some reason sex is funny to most of us. Conflict between the
characters is another convention that is prevalent. The characters are often
times depicted as angry with each other. In one scenario that the website
generated, one character actually stabbed the other. Yet another sad but true
thing about human nature is that we find conflict downright hilarious. This
generator also plays with conventions by slapping random elements of what we
expect from comic strips together with no rhyme or reason whatsoever.
The last generator we played around
with was a meme generator. A very common convention that the meme generator
used was images of famous people or references to famous people. This
convention is popular with memes because it creates humor that a large amount
of people can recognize. The memes generated also often portrayed situations
that a lot of people are able to relate with. For example, one meme said “Has online
assignments--- Weak wifi signal” with a picture of a highly irritated young
woman. Probably the most prevalent convention of all was the political jokes
and references. No matter what picture is attached, we all love a good dig at
Donald Trump.
Thinking about what these websites
do can help us understand the power that a genre’s conventions have over our
perception. By following conventions, SCIgen was able to make us believe that a
paper filled with nonsensical academic words was a highly complex and scholarly
paper. Likewise, the comic strip generator could put three completely random and
unrelated images next to each other and make us laugh because we felt like we
were supposed to be laughing. The meme generator could put a picture of a happy
puffin and a witty saying together and we would not stop to question the
relevance of the puffin. Conventions are so powerful that even when something
is not normal at all we can believe it to be solely because the conventions of
the genre are being followed.
It is crazy how many convetions surround genres,yet how we never really gave it much thought before this wiring assignment. I found similar conventions to the ones that you discovered in your blog. For example, the research papers included big words, the comic strips had crude humor, and the memes had humor easily recognized by most people. After reading your blog, I have come to realize even more so just how important conventions can be, I mean they have the ability to fool people into believing what these generators produce as being the truth. Your blog was very well organized and you included great examples!
ReplyDeleteI love how well organized your blog post is! The transition between each paragraph is smooth, and you connect the topics between the two paragraphs so that it flows. I thought it was interesting to note that you mentioned how the graphs are conveniently blurred. I had not even realized that! I love how you utilized a mixture of first and second order thinking, making your post both formal and informal in all the right doses. It made the post humorous and easy to read. I also loved how your conclusion was brief yet still went back to discuss each of the 3 websites and their significance.
ReplyDeleteJustice Kennedy,
ReplyDeleteLake-living and then Boston-living, huh? You’re making some wise decisions here.
One quick note before I continue: you might want to consider adjusting the # of posts setting on your blogger settings—it seems to be only show 3 at a time (i.e., your autobio blurb isn’t visible).
Re: PB1A, “Acknowledging that nearly everything we read belongs to a genre is the first step to really understanding all the conventions are attached to those genres” is spot-on. Woo hoo! You chose RATE MY PROF reviews?! Wow! That’s a new one. Very, very cool. I know an incredibly charming and cool dude named Zack on there…
Easiness/difficulty of the course, casual language, some spelling/punctuation mistakes… these could certainly be considered conventions of a RMP review. The writer’s purpose (to recommend or discourage) the instructor also deffffffinitely plays a role in making this genre its own unique genre. To dig a bit further, some other conventions include the $ required to take/participate in the course (think: textbooks), attendance policies, the specific courses offered/taught, how this instructor compares to another within the school/department, the # of rankings in the rating offered, the length/max posting limit, and so forth.
Re: PB1B, nice work. You nailed a lot of the conventions and I like how you gave specific textual examples in the cartoon genre. With respect to the meme genre analysis, I’d also like you to think about HOW everything is functioning. For instance, consider what those two lines are doing, i.e., the top/bottom line—it’s almost always a setup and then a punchline. Together, this kind of structure/system gives memes their rhetorical effect.
Good job here, Justice Kennedy. Include some pics/vids in future posts to spice up your blog and bring it to life just a bit more.
Z